........................................................................
ImperialExecutiveI'm either going to sell two of my high-age and high-mileage cars (I have three), or drive themb into a good scrapper and get some money for themb. I might get as high as $300 for each, but $200 each is more likely. (With my contacts I'll find a good scrapper, not the usual scum.)
Then I'm going to turn around and give the money to a friend who has a late 1990s Windstar, which has a blown head gasket. The HG I can replace myself. It will be the most involved repair that I've ever done by myself on a car, but there's nothing specifically daunting about the project. It just takes about 10hr of labor, at least by the billable time in the book.
The parts will be $250-300, being the gaskets, bolts, and oil and a/f.
Counting the $450 spent on the Windstar (which is my friend's price), that pushes my investment up to $800 at most.
Where's that inflation again, asscakes? 
........................................................................
You need to take the head to a machine shop and have it planed.
........................................................................
Windstar.
........................................................................
ImperialExecutivewrote:
You need to take the head to a machine shop and have it planed.
It's highly unlikely a blown head gasket is due to warpage. I'm not going to find the 3m across / 6m along difference. The current owner is used to gunning the engine in municipal vehicles, so he probably blew the gasket from running it hard. That reminds me, I've gotta check the head for signs of worn or decayed springs.
........................................................................
You can buy cars that run for that kind of money.
........................................................................
Care are worth more if they come with rubber tires instead of concrete blocks.
........................................................................
wrote:
You need to take the head to a machine shop and have it planed.
If you are referring IE's head, I believe you are correct. ![]()
........................................................................
ImperialExecutive wrote:
It's highly unlikely a blown head gasket is due to warpage. I'm not going to find the 3m across / 6m along difference. The current owner is used to gunning the engine in municipal vehicles, so he probably blew the gasket from running it hard. That reminds me, I've gotta check the head for signs of worn or decayed springs.
I'm not familiar with windstars, if it's an aluminum head it would be worth the money. A blown head gasket is usually a symptom of a problem. It would be worth the money to let a pro look it over(springs, cam(s), warp, etc)
........................................................................
ImperialExecutivewrote:
I'm not familiar with windstars, if it's an aluminum head it would be worth the money. A blown head gasket is usually a symptom of a problem. It would be worth the money to let a pro look it over(springs, cam(s), warp, etc)
The pro is just going to gauge it. I can gauge it. Why would I pay a guy what's really a lot of money, to do what I can do myself?
........................................................................
ImperialExecutivewrote:
I'm not familiar with windstars, if it's an aluminum head it would be worth the money.
I'm fairly sure the head is Al.
{googling}
Hmm, it seems I'm wrong. Some specs say cast iron block and cast iron head.
........................................................................
ImperialExecutive wrote:
I'm fairly sure the head is Al.
{googling}
Hmm, it seems I'm wrong. Some specs say cast iron block and cast iron head.
I would definitely have it checked if it's and Al head on a Fe block. I assume you know that head bolts/studs can't be reused. They are designed to be stretched only one time.
........................................................................
REALjesalurkerAs a Machinist with 40+ years experience, my honest opinion is stop doing ANYTHING; it's beyond your capabilities, you'll just be throwing money at a problem that has NO SATISFACTORY SOLUTION.
........................................................................
CliveWindstar 
........................................................................
Heekee wrote:
Windstar

........................................................................
ImperialExecutivewrote:
I would definitely have it checked if it's and Al head on a Fe block. I assume you know that head bolts/studs can't be reused. They are designed to be stretched only one time.
I checked. It's a cast iron head. That's more resistant to warpage. So it's likely the head blew from Mr Engine Gunner treating his Windstar like his muni vehicle.
Thanks about the bolts. I already knew that they aren't designed for more than one use. In fact, all bolts are like that. When torgued down to spec and then released, they lose something like 30% of their holding strength or reliability. When torgued down again and then released, they fall to something like 50%. Metallurgy is fascinating.
........................................................................
ImperialExecutiveNO ONE CAN REPAIR THEIR OWN VEHICLE! THOSE CHILTON AND HAYNES MANUALS ARE ONLY FOR SHOW!
/
Dickdogs.
........................................................................
ImperialExecutiveAbout the only job that I can't do on a car is honing of any sort. I've never done it and I have no confidence that I could do it properly. Since a honing operation tends to be critical, I'd pay somebody to do it for me.
........................................................................
DrifterBeeImperialExecutive wrote:
I checked. It's a cast iron head. That's more resistant to warpage. So it's likely the head blew from Mr Engine Gunner treating his Windstar like his muni vehicle.
Thanks about the bolts. I already knew that they aren't designed for more than one use. In fact, all bolts are like that. When torgued down to spec and then released, they lose something like 30% of their holding strength or reliability. When torgued down again and then released, they fall to something like 50%. Metallurgy is fascinating.
A few things. The job is a PITA. The engine is wedged in there. Try and get a welding sock to put around your arm, the exhaust manifold is in an inconvenient place..
If I recall, they used a variety of 3.0 and 3.8 engines in those things. Some were very prone to head gasket leaks because of the proximity of the water jackets to the cylinders.. Even if the metal is the same for block/head, make sure its truly flat. They also make better silicone gaskets for those things that blow less often.. The other issue is the O2 sensor is probably coated with antifreeze, something else I commonly replaced when I had to do a head gasket cause the O2 sensor will produce a false lean, the computer to feed additional fuel, and often fail emissions.
One of the reasons the minivans are so cheap used is that they are major pain to deal with if anything breaks. They are designed to last the duration of the factory warranty before bad shyt starts happening. Shyt thats really annoying to fix. Try changing the spark plugs, trivially simple on most cars, 1/2 of them are really tough to reach on the minivans. (GM/Ford/Chrysler - they're all mounted basically the same) The solution? 100k spark plugs, long out of warranty before the dealer has to deal with it..
If I really really had to do this job, I'd probably see if I could pull the suspension and drop the entire engine tranny and work on it that way. Often times the head gasket was just the initial complaint. Ya get in there and start finding leaking seals and dead water pumps and the extra time to drop the whole thing isn't that big of a deal.
A 2 post lift comes in VERY handy.
Edit: And that 10 hr # is bullshyt if you've never done one before..
........................................................................
ImperialExecutiveIf the engine runs rich or lean, the manual is fairly explicit that either produces much faster wear on the valves. I'll give that O2 sensor a look.
I have two garages and will put this thing in one of themb. Pulling the entire engine was a possibility, since it'll be drained anyway. The last timbe we did serious work like this, we pulled the engine to chase a bunch of oil leaks. While I had the crankshaft exposed, I examined the bearing surfaces and wisely decided to change those. That car (though old) has worked like a champ, except for eating some oil.
You're right about where the engine will come out. It can't possibly come out the top, whereas in my other vehicles (except for the van), it can. The suspension would have to be removed or moved aside, and the engine/tranny dropped to the ground. And I only said "tranny" just in case Heekee is reading this. 
........................................................................
Wilsons_FaceImperialExecutive wrote:
I checked. It's a cast iron head. That's more resistant to warpage. So it's likely the head blew from Mr Engine Gunner treating his Windstar like his muni vehicle.
Thanks about the bolts. I already knew that they aren't designed for more than one use. In fact, all bolts are like that. When torgued down to spec and then released, they lose something like 30% of their holding strength or reliability. When torgued down again and then released, they fall to something like 50%. Metallurgy is fascinating.
Warpage comes from the fact the engine probably overheated after the gasket blew. The head would expand into the area where the leakage occured.
In addition a machinist will gauge it on a fixture with a plane bar.
........................................................................
Wilsons_Face wrote:
Warpage comes from the fact the engine probably overheated after the gasket blew. The head would expand into the area where the leakage occured.
In addition a machinist will gauge it on a fixture with a plane bar.
Junk Science!
\
........................................................................
Wilsons_Face wrote:
Warpage comes from the fact the engine probably overheated after the gasket blew. The head would expand into the area where the leakage occured.
In addition a machinist will gauge it on a fixture with a plane bar.
I always thought you was a hen. Not that a hen can't be a mechanic.
........................................................................
DrifterBeeImperialExecutive wrote:
If the engine runs rich or lean, the manual is fairly explicit that either produces much faster wear on the valves. I'll give that O2 sensor a look.
I have two garages and will put this thing in one of themb. Pulling the entire engine was a possibility, since it'll be drained anyway. The last timbe we did serious work like this, we pulled the engine to chase a bunch of oil leaks. While I had the crankshaft exposed, I examined the bearing surfaces and wisely decided to change those. That car (though old) has worked like a champ, except for eating some oil.
You're right about where the engine will come out. It can't possibly come out the top, whereas in my other vehicles (except for the van), it can. The suspension would have to be removed or moved aside, and the engine/tranny dropped to the ground. And I only said "tranny" just in case Heekee is reading this.
So, I'd strongly urge pulling the whole engine/tranny if you wanna do this.. One of the "secrets" of these minivans is that they are hard to work on, so techs typically do the bare min. (Flat rates a bitch) Theres a leak thats gonna be hard to get to? I did not see that.
If you can get the thing a few feet in the air, it helps a lot. Pull the CV Axles, pump out the HVAC, and lower the entire thing out of the car.. Once it's down, the head gaskets easy to do and you'll probably find other things you didn't want to touch..
........................................................................
And check the transaxle - one of my friends had one of those and it also blew the head gasket - he fixed it, put the engine back and about 3000 miles later the clutch mechanism in the axle broke, so he had to pull it all out again...
........................................................................
ImperialExecutiveIt's FWD so pulling the entire engine seems more sensible. I'm gonna need a tranny jack, right? And then an engine hoist? It's not like I can just lift the thing by hand.
........................................................................
Previous | First | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Last | Next