........................................................................
SamplesBoihttps://www.nytimes.com/interactive/202 … r-ups.html
Arguing over the 10 most important days of the last 175 years, our panel of historians and scholars had some lively debates. Here’s a window into their deliberations.
When we asked our panelists to nominate possibilities for the most consequential days since The New York Times began publishing, they submitted more than 100 suggestions. The longlist of nominations contained both inevitable and surprising contenders: the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand and the fall of the Berlin Wall, for instance, alongside the 1872 establishment of Yellowstone National Park (“the birth of public land as an idea,” said the documentarian Ken Burns), and the 1971 national premiere of “Soul Train” (which “gave Black culture a national platform,” argued the scholar Henry Louis Gates Jr.).
Over several sessions, the assembled thinkers argued over which dates should make the final list of 10. The debates were lively and involved some very difficult decisions, not just over big themes in history — Do we need a date related to the Cold War? Is there a single date that might capture anti-colonialism? — but over which days, exactly, made sense to choose. For instance, when discussing changes in global communication, the panelists considered the first trans-Atlantic cable communication in 1858 (which “collapsed time and opened up new ways of transmitting information,” argued the historian Beverly Gage); the 2007 release of the iPhone (Burns called the smartphone “an extraordinary invention that has also imprisoned everyone who has one”); and changes in how Facebook sorted its news feed (“a synecdoche for the attention economy,” in the political scientist Henry Farrell’s view).
Below, presented in chronological order, you’ll find 10 days that didn’t quite make the final list — and how our panelists argued for and against them.
What days did we miss? What would you have included? Let us know in the comments or through this submission form.
The Day the American Era Began
April 25, 1854: The Gadsden Treaty is ratified.
A vintage color-coded map of the Western United States and territories.
The Western United States after the Gadsden Treaty.
Five years after the end of the Mexican-American War, the Gadsden Treaty formalized the United States’ purchase of nearly 30,000 square miles of land in present-day Arizona and New Mexico for $10 million. The treaty put an end to several years of simmering tensions between the countries, establishing the current-day southern border and completing the contiguous United States. Read More
Marie Arana: Americans, encouraged by their government, invaded Mexico, settled on its lands, usurped the territory, fought a war to keep it and then bought the land via the Gadsden Treaty. It was the usurpation — sealed and blessed and made legal by the treaty — that spurred a new American imperialism. America started going after the Dominican Republic, Cuba, Puerto Rico, Honduras, just one after another. And there was a scramble for Africa at that point. All that was sparked by this new American muscle, creating a kind of testosterone around the world.
Nell Irvin Painter: This new behemoth of a nation gave slavery (then illegal in Mexico but not in the U.S.) room to grow, economically, politically and humanly.
Christopher Caldwell: But we are talking about a puny, God-forsaken strip of southern Arizona. The U.S. landmass was already consolidated from coast to coast, and Gadsden does not have any special relevance to future U.S.-Mexican relations — certainly less than the acquisition of California five years before.
A snippet of vintage newsprint from The New York Daily Times.
The news of the Gadsden Treaty’s ratification ran on The Times’s front page the next day.
The Day That Fueled Industry
Aug. 27, 1859: Oil is drilled from the ground in Pennsylvania.
A vintage black and white photograph of two men wearing black suits and brimmed hats standing near a wooden oil well.
Edwin L. Drake (right) in 1861, two years after he conceived the idea of drilling for oil near Titusville, Pa., with Peter Wilson, a local druggist who supported the venture.
When the businessman Edwin L. Drake arrived in Titusville, Pa., in the late 1850s, he was on assignment from a burgeoning oil company to investigate areas where small amounts of oil pooled. Uninspired by the paltry output, Drake eventually developed a system in which pipe was drilled into the ground to reach oil deposits. On Aug. 27, 1859, he struck oil at a depth of 69 feet, setting off an oil boom in Pennsylvania and ushering in an era of commercial extraction. Read More
Dan Wang: We are substantially a fossil-fuel-based economy. The discovery of oil in Pennsylvania inaugurated quite a lot of the industrial production in the United States. There’s also the discovery of oil in Saudi Arabia in 1938, which shaped global geopolitics and helped create the power dynamics in the Middle East. Oil has probably been the best resource to have for the last century and a half.
Fred Turner: It’s hard to think of something more consequential for economies globally, for climate change globally, than the discovery of carbon fuels.
Wang: But now Trump is giving a big nuclear deal to the Saudis. The world wants to move away from burning oil and toward electric motors. And it wants to buy more solar and batteries, especially from China, because of that. And so if the future is not oil, then through a presentist lens, then I would argue against including the discovery of oil.
A snippet of vintage newsprint with headline announcing the presence of oil found in Pennsylvania.
A front-page report from The Times published in 1864, as the petroleum industry was booming.
The Day a Mile Got Short
April 3, 1885: The Daimler combustion engine is patented.
A black and white photo of a vintage motorbike.
The first motorbike, from Daimler and Maybach, built in 1885.
The German engineer Gottlieb Daimler had been working on engines for years when he — along with his collaborator Wilhelm Maybach — patented the “grandfather clock,” a single-cylinder, high-speed internal combustion engine that ran on gasoline. With this invention, Daimler and others (including the engineer Carl Benz) went on to invent the world’s first motorcycles, gas-powered “horseless carriages” and eventually the automobile. Read More
Beverly Gage: If I were to choose a transportation mode, I would choose the automobile over the airplane. It has such tangible effects on basically everything about the way most people live in the world.
Turner: The automobile story brings in the individuation of capitalism, the individualization of everyday life. It opens up the door to the mass industry and of course, air pollution.
Gage: It has climate effects and it has geographic effects. It enables the rise of the suburbs. People no longer need to live within walking distance of the places they shop and work, which was the case for most of humanity until the 20th century.
Henry Farrell: And with the automobile, you can now commit crime and get away with it. Then scamper 20 or 30 miles away, which leads to the creation of the F.B.I.
John Ganz: Without the combustion engine, there’s no tanks or planes, either. World War II is just all combustion engines.
Claudia Goldin: But if I had to, I’d pick electricity over the automobile.
The Day We Got Well
Sept. 28, 1928: Penicillin is discovered.
Alexander Fleming in 1943.
After returning from a summer vacation in 1928, the British researcher Alexander Fleming found that blobs of Penicillium notatum mold had grown in some of his petri dishes. Upon further inspection, he discovered that where the mold had grown, it prevented the growth of Staphylococcus, a form of harmful bacteria he was researching. In the early 1940s, scientists learned how to purify and mass-produce penicillin for human use to stop the spread of bacterial infection. Read More
Goldin: An astounding discovery that microscopic living things will destroy other microscopic living things that are trying to destroy us. We created a war among millions of microbes and came out the winner. And then we figured out how to do it chemically.
Gage: The 20th century’s drastic decrease in child mortality and increase in life expectancy transformed culture and politics as well, forcing new understandings of religious faith, public ritual, war, safety — literally, issues of life and death.
Goldin: If I look at the inventions that have happened in the past 175 years and I say today, Which one of these things, if it were removed, would I suffer the most? It would be antibiotics. Think about what makes us happy every day. It’s that we don’t have headaches. We don’t have toothaches. We don’t have gangrene. We can have surgery. We have increasing life expectancy for which we can partly thank penicillin.
Turner: I’m going to go with “Origin of Species” over that, with great pain. I don’t want to lose penicillin. But I will, and in a way it’s just raw intellectual prejudice: “Origin” is a book that sets the stage for all sorts of science to follow. It gives a framework on which things can be built.
A clip of vintage newsprint of a story about the recently discovered “wonder drug” penicillin.
Shortly after the drug became available to the general public, The Times Magazine introduced it to readers in a 1944 feature.
The Day the System Collapsed
Oct. 16, 1928: The banker Benjamin Strong dies, setting in motion the Great Depression.
Benjamin Strong
As the first leader of the New York Federal Reserve, Benjamin Strong was an unusually powerful banker. He had clear ideas about how the Fed should manage economic downturns, and close relationships with European central bankers. But in October 1928, he died after having surgery for an intestinal abscess. When Wall Street collapsed a year later, Strong’s absence left a paralyzed, divided Federal Reserve, transforming an ordinary stock market crash into a historic catastrophe, and paving the way for World War II. Read More
Ken Burns: The Great Depression is the greatest economic cataclysm in the history of the world. When Franklin Roosevelt was talking to his economist, he said, “Was there any precedent?” And they said, “Yes, the Dark Ages, which lasted 400 years.”
Goldin: To attach it to a date, I would say the death of Benjamin Strong, which created the power vacuum that set off the Great Depression, which led to years of bread lines in the U.S. and left a legacy of social insurance. America became a more modern economy because of it. It also destabilized much of Europe and led to World War II.
Rick Perlstein: The Great Depression is also kind of the birth of the modern socialist democratic idea that rights can’t be fully exercised unless there’s a floor beneath which nobody can fall. And the Lehman Brothers bankruptcy was when this idea was suspended for the duration — and was arguably the birth date of global populism.
Goldin: Because of what we learned in the 1920s, we didn’t have a Great Depression in 2008-2009. The ghost of Benjamin Strong taught Geithner and Bernanke a lesson, and prevented disaster.
Wang: May I speak against the Great Depression? I am not sure that the ripple effects of the Great Depression went much beyond South America and Europe. So first, it may be a little bit too domestic-focused, and second, you know, it is not that extraordinary.
Henry Louis Gates Jr.: There was actually another Great Depression in 1873. It was called the Great Depression until 1929, when the greater depression supplanted it.
Perlstein: There were a lot of depressions until the Great Depression, until we figured out how to stop them, until we took away the figuring-out-how-to-stop them.
A clip of vintage newsprint showing the obituary of Benjamin Strong, who died at 56.
Benjamin Strong’s 1928 Times obituary.
The Day the Empires Fell
Aug. 15, 1947: India and Pakistan become independent.
New Delhi on Aug. 15, 1947, the day India became independent.
The end of British rule following Parliament’s 1947 Indian Independence Act created two distinct states in South Asia: Hindu-majority India and Muslim-majority Pakistan. The hurried partition, enacted just weeks after British withdrawal from the subcontinent, initiated the largest mass displacement in human history — forcing roughly 15 million people from their homes amid militia violence. The partition ignited an enduring regional cold war, while establishing India’s position as the world’s largest democracy. Read More
Caldwell: The independence of India, wrapped up with the partition of India and Pakistan, is the biggest anticolonial struggle against the most dominant imperial power that the world had ever known. It’s a blow against this invincible-looking British Empire.
Siddhartha Mukherjee: The U.K. becomes no longer the center of geopolitics. Partition is an exemplar of the resetting of the world into the new world order.
Gates: It began the postwar collapse of the European empire, and ended the events that started with the Conference of Berlin in 1884 and 1885, where the colonial powers carved up Africa like they owned it. It closes the loop.
Mukherjee: And it basically creates India as the single largest democracy, by population, on the planet.
Turner: The independence of India and Pakistan inspired anticolonial movements worldwide.
Mukherjee: You can draw a line very obviously from Gandhi to M.L.K. Jr. Civil disobedience as a concept is an incredibly important concept in human history. But it’s hard to justify why the partition of these particular two nations — or three, in the case, ultimately, of Bangladesh — makes it to our list, whereas a bajillion other freedom movements and decolonizations across the world don’t make it to the list. What is so special about 1947 that is not special about, for instance, the Belgians leaving Africa? Or a date that captures the consequences of the slave trade?
A map of the newly partitioned region, which ran the next day on the front page of The Times.
The Day the Paranoia Set In
Nov. 22, 1963: Kennedy is assassinated.
President John F. Kennedy and Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis smiling in the back seat of an open-top car flanked by police motorcycles.
President John F. Kennedy in Dallas on Nov. 22, 1963.
On a sunny Friday afternoon in Dallas, President John F. Kennedy was shot while waving to crowds from the back seat of an open-topped Lincoln Continental. Even though Lee Harvey Oswald was charged with the murder — before being killed a day later by Jack Ruby — much of the public believed Kennedy’s death to be part of a larger conspiracy. Read More
Caldwell: The assassination of J.F.K. — the sudden, mysterious murder of a charismatic leader — darkened American life and hangs, unresolved, over the country six decades later. It also placed the far less stable Lyndon Johnson in charge of reorganizing society at home and laying down the law abroad.
Arana: Some have called it the birth of modern American conspiracy culture. But I don’t think that’s true. In the 19th century, there was the conspiracy theory that secret societies like the Freemasons were really running the country. Then, preceding the Civil War, there was the notion that slaveholders were pulling all the strings in the federal government. And when President Garfield was assassinated in 1881, there was a strong suspicion that a secret plot was behind the killing. So J.F.K.’s assassination certainly wasn’t the first to prompt that fear.
Ganz: J.F.K.’s assassination was not a big deal. In retrospect, who cares?
Perlstein: A big deal, but not a big deal.
Ganz: Not a big deal.
Perlstein: Not even top five global assassinations.
Gage: It doesn’t have global significance.
Ganz: People don’t care about it anymore.
The front page of The New York Times from Saturday, Nov. 23, 1963.
The Times’s coverage of Kennedy’s assassination filled the first 16 pages of the Nov. 23, 1963, paper.
The Day the Universe Opened Up
July 20, 1969: The Apollo 11 mission puts humans on the moon.
Buzz Aldrin, in a photo taken by his fellow astronaut Neil Armstrong, on the surface of the moon, July 1969.
When Neil Armstrong took his first steps on the moon, an estimated one-fifth of the world watched live on television. The Apollo 11 mission was the culmination of a yearslong “space race” between the United States and the Soviet Union. But across the globe, humanity was mesmerized by a moment that seemed to transcend Cold War borders and mark a collective turning point in the history of civilization. Read More
Mukherjee: The moon landing sets off a whole technological revolution, it announces American dominance in space. It starts off the satellite revolution. I mean, there’s a whole space universe that opens up.
Ganz: Space. I guess space is pretty big.
Turner: I proposed it and I’ll defend it. We just have to acknowledge it’s the first time our species, so far as we know, has landed on another body. That’s just flat-out a big deal. And it’s an extraordinary moment at which millions of people around the world watch media together. It’s one of those moments when the global village actually exists for a few minutes.
Perlstein: It was so important that we didn’t try doing it again for 50 years.
Caldwell: Yeah, and can’t do it again, actually.
Mukherjee: The entire global communication system begins to sort of wrap itself around the globe in ways that you can trace back to the first rocket.
Ganz: Yeah, something changed. In “The Human Condition,” by Hannah Arendt, she begins the book by saying the most important thing that happened is that we left the confines of the world. And this completely reconfigured the way people think about humanity.
Turner: It sparked a level of new technological innovation. An entire generation of young people in what will become Silicon Valley are watching this. When you ask them where it was that they began to think they wanted to be an engineer, where they began to get this idea that there would be an electronic frontier, a lot of them will cite the space program.
Caldwell: I just don’t feel like the consequences of the moon landing have ripened yet.
Ganz: It’s a too-early-to-tell situation, but it is pretty crazy that we went there.
Front page of The New York Times from July 21, 1969, with a headline reading: MEN WALK ON THE MOON.
The front page of The New York Times on Monday, July 21, 1969.
The Day the World Watched America Fall
Sept. 11, 2001: Al Qaeda attacks the United States.
The wreckage of the World Trade Center, Sept. 11, 2001.
When the first plane struck the World Trade Center’s North Tower at 8:46 a.m. on Sept. 11, 2001, many speculated that it was an accident. Seventeen minutes later, a second plane hit the South Tower. In the end, the 9/11 attacks claimed nearly 3,000 lives, launched the United States’ “global war on terror” and shattered America’s sense of invulnerability. Read More
Perlstein: 9/11 did a bunch of things. It caused a certain kind of structural surrender to fear in American life, without which Trump is impossible.
Ganz: It seemed like after 1989 there was a fairly stable world order and that it was just a matter of time before things went a certain way. And I think 9/11 did really shake the notion that things were trending in a stable direction.
Perlstein: 9/11 turned us into a “bed-wetter nation,” in which everyone lowers several levels down Maslow’s hierarchy of needs until they’re just protecting the tribe and the enclave.
Caldwell: You can also partly trace to 9/11 the discrediting of the federal government as a repository of common sense. And the sense among the public that you can really move an entire, huge, sophisticated nation onto a stupid course of action based on really flimsy evidence. That had a devastating effect on the credibility of institutions and politicians. But it was not the only factor there.
Ganz: For the generation coming up that either was very young when it happened or not even born yet, its significance is very different. It does not have the same emotional content or the same, Oh, well, that’s when the world changed.
Perlstein: Well, they just don’t know. They just don’t know where the fact that everyone has to live their lives cowering in fear and clamoring for security — that’s where it came from.
Gage: 9/11 seems to me like a really interesting example where, if you had been doing this exercise five years out from that day, everyone would have said: 9/11 is the date that changed everything, that launched the 21st century. And now that we’re 25 years out from it, it just looks really, really different.
The front page of The New York Times from Wednesday, Sept. 12, 2001.
The Day Attention Became Power
June 16, 2015: Trump descends the golden escalator.
Donald J. Trump on the day he announced he was entering the presidential race in 2015.
Donald Trump’s entry into the 2016 presidential race was not exactly unexpected: He teased interest in running in several previous elections. But then he declared his candidacy in the atrium of Trump Tower in 2015, gliding down the golden escalator in his red tie as Neil Young’s “Rockin’ in the Free World” blasted from loudspeakers. Few people predicted that he would clinch the Republican nomination, let alone dominate global politics for years to come. Read More
Goldin: What about the election of Donald Trump?
Caldwell: Or his descent down the golden escalator in 2015, when he announced his presidential candidacy. I think that a very strong case can be made that June of 2015 is a turning point.
Turner: I’ve thought a lot about where Trump fits. I’m increasingly convinced that he’s a passing phenomenon. What makes him unique is that he is an American authoritarian. And we haven’t had an American authoritarian before.
Caldwell: One lasting effect of Trump is likely to be the privatization of government.
Painter: For me, if Trump were a true turning point, it would be for the decline of the United States, the end of the postwar era, which is the end of the 20th century basically, taking us into we don’t know what or where or how. And also the impossibility of dealing with climate, which is part of the Trump legacy, puts us in another totally scary place.
Caldwell: Trump is a serious contender for our list, but it’s too early. It’s very important that all of these places with authoritarians still have elections. Orban was voted out of power, Bolsonaro was voted out of power and Trump was voted out of power (before he was voted back in again). And most of our institutions still hold. However, there are signs that the Trump era could open up into something else. And we could be saying of Western society what George W. Bush said of the United States’ economy during the finance crisis: This sucker could go down. But the truth is, we don’t yet know.
........................................................................
........................................................................
Previous | First | 1 | Last | Next